Korean J Health Promot > Volume 25(2); 2025 > Article |
|
AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS
Dr. Muhammad Ajmal DINA had full access to all of the data in the study and takes responsibility for the integrity of the data and the accuracy of the data analysis. All authors reviewed this manuscript and agreed to individual contributions.
Conceptualization: MAD. Data curation: MAD. Formal analysis: AA. Methodology: AA. Writing–original draft: AA. Writing–review & editing: all authors.
Study (year) | Global/National | Stakeholders | Aims | Information requirements | Scope | Source | Gaps, challenges |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
WHO (2021) | Global | Governments, WHO, UN Agencies | Develop and implement global AMR action plans; promote One Health approach | Data on AMR prevalence, antibiotic use, and resistance patterns globally | Global surveillance and policy-making | WHO reports, GLASS (Global Antimicrobial Resistance and Use Surveillance System) | Lack of standardized data collection; limited resources in low-income countries [16] |
O’Neill (2016) | Global | Researchers, Policymakers | Reduce antibiotic misuse in humans and animals; incentivize new drug R&D | Evidence on antibiotic misuse; economic models for R&D incentives | Global policy and research funding | Review on Antimicrobial Resistance | High cost of new drug development; slow progress in antibiotic innovation [17] |
CDC (2019) | National | Public Health Agencies, Healthcare | Strengthen infection prevention; improve antibiotic stewardship programs | Data on hospital-acquired infections; antibiotic prescribing practices | National healthcare systems | CDC reports, NHSN (National Healthcare Safety Network) | Inconsistent implementation of stewardship programs; lack of awareness among providers [18] |
FAO (2016) | Global/National | Agriculture Sector, Farmers | Reduce antibiotic use in livestock; promote alternatives to growth promoters | Data on antibiotic use in agriculture; alternatives to antibiotics | Agriculture and food production | FAO reports, national agricultural surveys | Resistance to change in farming practices; lack of affordable alternatives [19] |
OIE (2016) | Global | Veterinarians, Animal Health Sector | Set standards for responsible antibiotic use in animals | Data on veterinary antibiotic use; resistance trends in animals | Animal health and veterinary medicine | OIE standards, veterinary surveillance systems | Limited enforcement of standards; lack of global coordination [20] |
EU (2017) | Regional | EU Member States, Healthcare, Agriculture | Implement One Health Action Plan across human, animal, and environmental sectors | Integrated data on AMR across sectors | EU member states | EU AMR reports, ECDC (European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control) | Fragmented data systems; varying implementation across countries [21] |
Wellcome Trust (2020) | Global | Researchers, Funders, NGOs | Fund research on new diagnostics, vaccines, and treatments for AMR | Research priorities; funding mechanisms for AMR innovation | Global research and development | Wellcome Trust reports, research publications | Limited funding for AMR research; slow translation of research into practice [22] |
NIH (2021) | National/Global | Researchers, Healthcare Providers | Explore alternative therapies (e.g., phage therapy, immunotherapy) | Data on efficacy and safety of alternative therapies | Human health and clinical research | NIH research grants, clinical trial data | Regulatory hurdles; limited clinical trials for alternative therapies [23] |
UK Government (2019) | National | Government, Healthcare, Public | Implement 20-year vision for AMR; reduce antibiotic resistance through innovation | Long-term AMR trends; public awareness data | National healthcare and public policy | UK AMR strategy documents, public health reports | Sustaining long-term commitment; engaging the public in AMR efforts [24] |
Fleming (1929) | Historical | Scientists, Healthcare | Highlight the importance of responsible antibiotic use to prevent resistance | Historical data on antibiotic discovery and resistance emergence | Historical context of AMR | Scientific publications, historical records | Early recognition of resistance risks; lack of global coordination in early years [25] |
AMR, antimicrobial resistance; CDC, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention; EU, European Union; FAO, Food and Agriculture Organization; NGOs, nongovernmental organizations; NIH, National Institutes of Health; OIE, World Organization for Animal Health; R&D, Research and Development; UN, United Nations; WHO, World Health Organization.
Study (year) | Country | Program initiative | Description | Suggested interventions |
---|---|---|---|---|
Kumar et al. (2021) | India | National Action Plan on AMR | A comprehensive, multi-sectoral strategy to combat AMR through improved surveillance, stewardship, and public awareness | Strengthen community education campaigns, enforce stricter antibiotic prescribing guidelines, and enhance laboratory capacity for resistance testing [31] |
Adeyemi et al. (2020) | Nigeria | Nigeria AMR National Action Plan | Focuses on curbing the misuse of antibiotics in both human health and animal agriculture | Implement stricter regulations on over-the-counter antibiotic sales, promote vaccination programs to reduce infection rates, and improve monitoring of antibiotic use in livestock [32] |
Rahman et al. (2019) | Bangladesh | AMR Surveillance Network | Tracks and analyzes antibiotic resistance patterns in hospitals and community settings | Expand surveillance systems to rural and underserved areas, and provide training for healthcare workers on AMR prevention and management [33] |
Mwangi et al. (2022) | Kenya | Kenya AMR Strategy | Aims to reduce AMR through enhanced IPC measures in healthcare facilities | Increase funding for IPC infrastructure, promote nationwide hand hygiene campaigns, and integrate AMR education into medical training curricula [34] |
Khan et al. (2018) | Pakistan | Drug Resistance Monitoring Initiative | Monitors antibiotic resistance trends in clinical settings to inform policy and practice | Establish a national antibiotic usage registry, enforce prescription-only policies for antibiotics, and improve public awareness about the dangers of self-medication [35] |
Tadesse et al. (2021) | Ethiopia | One Health AMR Program | Integrates human, animal, and environmental health approaches to address AMR holistically | Strengthen collaboration between health, agriculture, and environmental sectors, and improve waste management systems to reduce environmental contamination with antibiotics [36] |
Mushi et al. (2020) | Tanzania | Tanzania AMR Framework | Focuses on reducing antibiotic misuse in both healthcare and agricultural sectors | Educate farmers on alternatives to antibiotics in livestock, regulate veterinary antibiotic use, and promote sustainable farming practices [37] |
Nalubega et al. (2019) | Uganda | Uganda AMR Control Program | Addresses AMR through policy development, public awareness campaigns, and healthcare worker training | Develop and disseminate AMR guidelines for healthcare facilities, and launch nationwide public awareness campaigns to educate communities about responsible antibiotic use [38] |
Osei et al. (2022) | Ghana | Ghana AMR Partnership | Aims to improve antibiotic use in hospitals and communities through stewardship and education | Train pharmacists and clinicians on rational antibiotic prescribing, strengthen diagnostic capacity to reduce unnecessary antibiotic use, and establish antibiotic stewardship programs in hospitals [39] |
Nguyen et al. (2018) | Vietnam | Vietnam AMR National Action Plan | Focuses on reducing AMR in healthcare and livestock through policy and practice changes | Promote the use of antibiotic alternatives in agriculture, improve hospital IPC practices, and enhance surveillance of resistance patterns [40] |
Santos et al. (2021) | Philippines | AMR Surveillance and Stewardship | Monitors resistance patterns and promotes responsible antibiotic use in healthcare settings | Expand access to rapid diagnostic tools, implement antibiotic stewardship programs in hospitals, and increase public awareness about AMR [41] |
van Niekerk et al. (2020) | South Africa | AMR National Strategy Framework | Aims to reduce AMR through research, policy implementation, and public engagement | Fund AMR research initiatives, enforce stricter regulations on antibiotic use, and integrate AMR education into school curricula [42] |
Thapa et al. (2019) | Nepal | Nepal AMR Prevention Initiative | Focuses on reducing AMR in healthcare settings through improved practices and policies | Improve access to diagnostic tools, train healthcare workers on AMR prevention, and develop national guidelines for antibiotic use [43] |
Wijaya et al. (2022) | Indonesia | Indonesia AMR Control Program | Targets AMR through public awareness campaigns and healthcare system interventions | Launch mass media campaigns to educate the public, strengthen antibiotic prescription guidelines, and improve monitoring of antibiotic use in hospitals [44] |
Aung et al. (2021) | Myanmar | Myanmar AMR Action Plan | Aims to reduce AMR through enhanced surveillance, education, and policy development | Develop educational materials on AMR for healthcare workers and the public, and improve data collection systems to track resistance trends [1] |
Anam ARSHED
https://orcid.org/0009-0009-4907-8814
Muhammad Ajmal DINA
https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2034-5084